WordPress & SEO Blog

Actionable WordPress and SEO Tips & Tricks to Improve Your Website

WordPress Plugin Updates: How to Bulletproof the Process and Prevent Site Breakage

Why Keeping WordPress Plugins and Core Updated Matters

Your WordPress website is only as strong as its weakest plugin. Every plugin you install adds features, but it also adds code that needs regular care. When that code becomes outdated, it becomes an open door for hackers, a source of bugs, and a drag on performance.

Outdated plugins are one of the most common ways WordPress sites get hacked. Developers release updates to patch security holes, fix bugs, and keep their plugins compatible with the latest versions of WordPress core and PHP. Skip those updates, and your site falls a little further behind with every release.

But here’s the catch: updates can also break things. A plugin that played nicely last week might clash with your theme, your page builder, or another plugin after an update. Suddenly your contact form stops sending, your checkout page goes blank, or you’re staring at the dreaded “There has been a critical error on this website” message.

The good news? You don’t have to choose between a secure site and a working one. With the right process, you can keep everything current without crossing your fingers every time you click “Update.”

Automatic vs. Manual Updates: Which Is Better?

Since WordPress 5.5, you’ve been able to turn on automatic updates for individual plugins with a single click, and many hosts offer their own auto-update tools. It’s tempting to flip the switch and forget about it. Before you do, let’s look at both sides.

The Case for Automatic Updates

Auto-updates do have real benefits:

  • Speed: Security patches are applied soon after they’re released, often before you’d even hear about a vulnerability.
  • Convenience: No logging in, no clicking, no remembering.
  • Consistency: Updates happen even when you’re busy or on vacation.

Why I Recommend Manual Updates for Most Business Sites

For a simple blog with a handful of plugins, auto-updates might be fine. But for a business website that generates leads or sales, I recommend manual updates for nearly everything. Here’s why:

  • You won’t know when something breaks. Auto-updates run in the background, often overnight. If an update breaks your site at 2 a.m., you might not find out until a customer tells you or the leads stop coming in.
  • There’s no backup safety net. WordPress’s built-in auto-updates don’t take a backup first. If something goes wrong, rolling back is on you.
  • Nobody reads the changelog. Major version jumps sometimes include breaking changes that a quick look at the release notes would have flagged.
  • Updates pile up together. When several plugins update at once, figuring out which one caused the problem turns into a guessing game.
  • Complex sites have more moving parts. WooCommerce stores, membership sites, and sites built with Elementor rely on plugins that depend on each other. One mismatched version can take down an entire checkout.

Pro Tip: Let WordPress keep applying minor core security releases automatically (it does this by default), but keep plugin and theme updates manual. If you do enable auto-updates for a few low-risk plugins, set up uptime monitoring so you’ll know right away if your site goes down.

The Safest Way to Update WordPress Plugins

Updating plugins safely isn’t complicated. It just takes a little discipline. Here’s the step-by-step process I follow on client sites (and it fits right into a monthly WordPress maintenance routine).

1. Back Up Your Entire Site

Before you touch a single update, make a full backup of your files and database. Use a reliable plugin like UpdraftPlus or your host’s backup tool, and store a copy offsite. A backup you can’t restore is no backup at all, so make sure you know how to use it before you need it.

2. Read the Changelogs

Take a couple of minutes to read the release notes for each update. You’ll find them under “View version details” on the Plugins screen. Major version jumps (like 3.9 to 4.0), new PHP requirements, or removed features all deserve extra caution.

3. Test on a Staging Site First

A staging site is a private copy of your website where you can test changes without affecting visitors. Many managed WordPress hosts include one-click staging. Run your updates there first, click around, and make sure everything works before touching the live site.

4. Update One Plugin at a Time

Resist the “Update All” button. Update plugins one at a time and check your site after each one. If something breaks, you’ll know exactly which plugin caused it.

5. Be Patient With Major Releases

When a major WordPress core release or a big plugin version drops, give it a week or so. That gives developers time to squash early bugs and lets other plugins catch up. Security releases are the exception: apply those promptly.

6. Clear Your Cache and Test Key Features

Clear your caching plugin, server cache, and CDN so you’re seeing the real updated site. Then test what matters most to your business:

  • Contact and lead forms
  • Checkout and payment gateways
  • Booking, login, and membership areas
  • Menus and layouts on mobile

7. Have a Rollback Plan

If something breaks, don’t panic. Restore from your backup, or use a plugin like WP Rollback to return a WordPress.org plugin to its previous version. Then check the plugin’s support forum. Chances are you’re not the only one with the issue.

Pro Tip: Keep a simple log of what you updated and when. If a problem shows up days later, you’ll have a head start figuring out what changed.

WordPress Plugin Update FAQ

Q1. How often should I update my WordPress plugins?
Check for updates at least once a week and apply security updates as soon as possible. For everything else, a weekly or every-other-week schedule works well for most business sites.

Q2. Is it safe to click “Update All”?
It’s convenient, but risky. If something breaks, you won’t know which update caused it. Updating one at a time takes a few extra minutes and can save hours of troubleshooting.

Q3. What should I do if a plugin update breaks my site?
Restore your backup or roll the plugin back to its previous version. If you’re locked out of your dashboard, you can disable the plugin by renaming its folder in /wp-content/plugins/ using FTP or your host’s file manager. WordPress may also email you a recovery mode link. Still stuck? That’s what my WordPress repair service is for.

Q4. Do I need to update plugins I’m not using?
Delete them instead. Even inactive plugins can be exploited if their code is outdated.

Q5. What if a plugin hasn’t been updated in a long time?
A plugin that hasn’t seen an update in a year or more may be abandoned. Look for an actively maintained alternative, especially if it handles forms, payments, or user data.

Q6. Do I really need a staging site?
For a small brochure site, a solid backup may be enough. For eCommerce, membership, or lead-generating sites, a staging site is some of the cheapest insurance you can buy.

Let Me Handle Your WordPress Updates

If you’d rather spend your time running your business than babysitting plugin updates, I can help. My WordPress maintenance services include safe, tested updates for plugins, themes, and core, regular offsite backups, security monitoring, and fast fixes if something does go wrong. No tech jargon, no surprises, just a website that keeps working for you.

Cynthia Turcotte is a freelance WordPress developer with over 25 years of web development and SEO experience. She lives in Deland, Florida with her husband and two grown sons and enjoys cooking, reading, old-school paper-and-dice roleplaying games (D&D and BESM FTW!), and debating the merits of food sharing with her dog.

Each week I will be publishing new tips and tricks to help you improve the function and speed of your WordPress website and help you get the most out of the #1 CMS in the world! Got a tip or trick that is part of your regular WordPress arsenal? Send me an email and tell me about it!